You’re a Nameless Troll. What Do You Need Rights For?

trolls-madison-ave.jpg

Yesterday AgencySpy reposted an op-ed by Alan Wolk that generated a shit-ton of loose-cannon commentary.

There’s a lot to be said about the culture of anonymous commenting — that it lets people say things they wouldn’t normally, which can be both good and bad.

But imagine a world where everybody who ever wanted to talk to you had to reveal all his name and contact information first. Sure it’d minimize a few random acts of verbal cruelty, but is a full-disclosure world one you’d want to live in? And can the ideal be scaled to the ‘net in a practical way?

We went over other grays in this discourse last week while Wolk’s post was still hot, but the topic’s so milkable we figure this merits a poll.

Should anonymous comments be banned from the ‘net?

  
pollcode.com free polls

Picture of Steve Hall

Steve Hall

RECENT ARTICLES

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

I worked full-time while raising a one-year-old and maintaining a marriage and by month ten I was overwhelmed in the supermarket aisle because I realized I had optimized my entire life for efficiency but forgotten to leave space for joy

I worked full-time while raising a one-year-old and maintaining a marriage and by month ten I was overwhelmed in the supermarket aisle because I realized I had optimized my entire life for efficiency but forgotten to leave space for joy

Global English Editing

I’m 38 and I just realized my Boomer parents don’t call me for advice — they call me to hear their own thoughts repeated back in a younger voice because somewhere in the last 5 years they stopped trusting their own judgment and my job isn’t to have answers anymore, it’s to make their answers sound valid, and I don’t know when that shift happened but I know exactly what it cost them to need it

I’m 38 and I just realized my Boomer parents don’t call me for advice — they call me to hear their own thoughts repeated back in a younger voice because somewhere in the last 5 years they stopped trusting their own judgment and my job isn’t to have answers anymore, it’s to make their answers sound valid, and I don’t know when that shift happened but I know exactly what it cost them to need it

Global English Editing

9 signs you’ve quietly become the most self-aware person in your social circle — and why it sometimes feels lonelier, not better

9 signs you’ve quietly become the most self-aware person in your social circle — and why it sometimes feels lonelier, not better

Global English Editing

People who have no close friends but seem socially successful often share these 9 traits that explain why they’re surrounded by people but known by no one

People who have no close friends but seem socially successful often share these 9 traits that explain why they’re surrounded by people but known by no one

Global English Editing

The loneliest sound in a retired person’s house isn’t silence — it’s the refrigerator cycling on at 2pm because when the house is that quiet your brain starts cataloguing every mechanical sound just to confirm you’re still inside a life that’s running

The loneliest sound in a retired person’s house isn’t silence — it’s the refrigerator cycling on at 2pm because when the house is that quiet your brain starts cataloguing every mechanical sound just to confirm you’re still inside a life that’s running

Global English Editing

I’m 66 and the biggest lesson I learned too late wasn’t about saving more money or traveling sooner – it was understanding that every time I said ‘I’m fine’ when I wasn’t, I was teaching people that my feelings didn’t require their attention

I’m 66 and the biggest lesson I learned too late wasn’t about saving more money or traveling sooner – it was understanding that every time I said ‘I’m fine’ when I wasn’t, I was teaching people that my feelings didn’t require their attention

Global English Editing