Even More Time Wasted Critiquing Dumb Commercials

dr_scholls_yaya_dacosta.jpg

So we do a lot of ad critique around here at Adrants. Sometimes it’s worthy, other times it’s the digital equivalent of a newspaper used for dog defecation. In what has to be the most ridiculous critique of a ridiculous ad EVAR, MSNBC Ads of the Weird takes on a Dr. Scholl’s ad featuring America’s Next Top Model Runner Up Yaya DaCosta who dances on a desk and then jumps into a pair of shoes which, naturally, have Dr. Scholl’s inserts.

In what has become my favorite phrase of the week, “It’s just a fucking ad!”, this MSNBC Ads of the Weird critique is yet another giant WTF. I watched the ad before reading the MSNBC piece and I was like what? Huh? What’s wrong with this ad? It’s not great but it’s hardly worth attention. I better read to find out. Jesus. I thought I was the King of Making Something out of Nothing but after reading the MSNBC piece, I officially hand the reigns over to MSNBC Ads of the Weird for truly trumping anyone who has ever tried to elevate the mundane to the salacious and spectacular.

Picture of Steve Hall

Steve Hall

RECENT ARTICLES

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

I found a letter my father wrote to my mother before I was born — and the 3 sentences in it that he never said out loud to anyone in our family while he was alive changed how I understand every conversation he had with me for 40 years

I found a letter my father wrote to my mother before I was born — and the 3 sentences in it that he never said out loud to anyone in our family while he was alive changed how I understand every conversation he had with me for 40 years

Global English Editing

The art of the Sunday call: 8 things that happen psychologically during a 12-minute phone call with an aging parent that neither person will ever name but both people feel

The art of the Sunday call: 8 things that happen psychologically during a 12-minute phone call with an aging parent that neither person will ever name but both people feel

Global English Editing

Psychology says the person who is kind to everyone and close to no one isn’t always lacking in the capacity for intimacy — they’re managing their exposure to it, and management and intimacy are fundamentally incompatible, which is why the closeness they’re managing against never quite arrives

Psychology says the person who is kind to everyone and close to no one isn’t always lacking in the capacity for intimacy — they’re managing their exposure to it, and management and intimacy are fundamentally incompatible, which is why the closeness they’re managing against never quite arrives

Global English Editing

Women who have developed something genuinely beautiful in their character by the time they reach their 60s and 70s aren’t the ones who were always kind — they’re the ones who went through enough to become bitter and chose something else instead, who were let down enough times to close off and decided to remain open anyway

Women who have developed something genuinely beautiful in their character by the time they reach their 60s and 70s aren’t the ones who were always kind — they’re the ones who went through enough to become bitter and chose something else instead, who were let down enough times to close off and decided to remain open anyway

Global English Editing

People who have quietly accumulated real financial security over a lifetime don’t talk about money the way people who are trying to signal wealth do — they’re unhurried, they never seem to be calculating, they replace things when they wear out rather than when they impress, and there’s a specific quality of ease in how they move through the world that has nothing to do with spending and everything to do with never once having to wonder whether they can

People who have quietly accumulated real financial security over a lifetime don’t talk about money the way people who are trying to signal wealth do — they’re unhurried, they never seem to be calculating, they replace things when they wear out rather than when they impress, and there’s a specific quality of ease in how they move through the world that has nothing to do with spending and everything to do with never once having to wonder whether they can

Global English Editing

I’m 65 and I spent my entire adult life being the most competent person in every room I entered and it took a therapist asking me one very quiet question at 63 to help me understand that the competence wasn’t confidence — it was the strategy of a child who learned that being needed was the closest available substitute for being loved

I’m 65 and I spent my entire adult life being the most competent person in every room I entered and it took a therapist asking me one very quiet question at 63 to help me understand that the competence wasn’t confidence — it was the strategy of a child who learned that being needed was the closest available substitute for being loved

Global English Editing