Did Weiden + Kennedy Really Copy Young & Rubicon’s Milk Ad?

yotvata_sleepwalker.jpg

So yea. Another copycat accusation. As malicious as these things can be, most of the time, they are pure coincidence. Most people aren’t stupid enough to blatantly rip of another’s work. Well, at least we like to hope that’s the case.

Anyway, the current copycat of the month is, allegedly, Weiden + Kennedy which has been accused of copying a 2002 Israeli Yotvata milk commercial created by Young and Rubicam. The ad in question is W+K’s Sleepwalker ad for Coke.

For its part, Weiden + Kennedy said, “When we created the Coca-Cola ‘Sleepwalker’ commercial we and our agency were unaware of this other ad,” Coca-Cola representative Susan Stribling wrote in an email. “Now that we’ve seen the ad, we think both commercials are equally entertaining. While the two share a few common elements, any similarities are coincidental and unintended.”

Give it a watch:

What do you think?

Picture of Steve Hall

Steve Hall

RECENT ARTICLES

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

I’m 65 and I haven’t had a close friend in twelve years and I’m not lonely – I’m just finally honest about the fact that most friendships were performance anxiety disguised as connection

I’m 65 and I haven’t had a close friend in twelve years and I’m not lonely – I’m just finally honest about the fact that most friendships were performance anxiety disguised as connection

Global English Editing

There’s a specific kind of person who celebrates their dog’s birthday with real cake and real presents and real tears when the dog doesn’t understand any of it. That person isn’t performing love for the dog. They’re finally giving themselves permission to celebrate without anyone judging whether the occasion is important enough.

There’s a specific kind of person who celebrates their dog’s birthday with real cake and real presents and real tears when the dog doesn’t understand any of it. That person isn’t performing love for the dog. They’re finally giving themselves permission to celebrate without anyone judging whether the occasion is important enough.

Global English Editing

The loneliest people in most families aren’t the ones who left or struggled—they’re the ones who became the bank, because once you’re seen as the solution to everyone’s problems, nobody sees you as a person who might have problems of your own

The loneliest people in most families aren’t the ones who left or struggled—they’re the ones who became the bank, because once you’re seen as the solution to everyone’s problems, nobody sees you as a person who might have problems of your own

Global English Editing

People who can sit in silence with another person without needing to fill the space with conversation aren’t socially awkward — they’ve reached a level of relational security where presence is enough and words are optional

People who can sit in silence with another person without needing to fill the space with conversation aren’t socially awkward — they’ve reached a level of relational security where presence is enough and words are optional

Global English Editing

Children who were always told ‘you’re so mature for your age’ often carry these 8 traits into adulthood — including a deep exhaustion they can never fully explain because they’ve been performing capability since before they had any

Children who were always told ‘you’re so mature for your age’ often carry these 8 traits into adulthood — including a deep exhaustion they can never fully explain because they’ve been performing capability since before they had any

Global English Editing

Psychology says people who struggle with self-love don’t actually hate themselves — they’re operating with a nervous system that was trained to interpret self-criticism as protection, and kindness toward themselves triggers the same alarm bells that kept them safe when when they were small

Psychology says people who struggle with self-love don’t actually hate themselves — they’re operating with a nervous system that was trained to interpret self-criticism as protection, and kindness toward themselves triggers the same alarm bells that kept them safe when when they were small

Global English Editing