A Well-Intended Rip-Off’s Still a Rip-Off, Frankly

awareness-test.jpg

Check out this “Awareness Test” for Transport of London. The goal is to demonstrate that a driver can’t avoid obstacles s/he doesn’t expect to see. For people who’ve never seen the video before, it probably comes across as a neat way to deliver the message.

The problem is, there are plenty of people who have already seen something similar — likely this video, which was put together in 1999 by Professor Daniel Simons of the University of Illinois.

The videos sparked a copyright debate between WCRS and Professor Simons. He said he liked the goal of the campaign, but would have collaborated with the agency to find an “awareness test” more appropriate to their purposes if they contacted him instead of just ripping off his idea.

The debacle was put to our attention by Scamp, who in closing asks, “if the goal of the ad is to save lives, as in this case…. should we really feel so bad?”

Picture of Steve Hall

Steve Hall

RECENT ARTICLES

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

Psychology says the reason some people become warmer and more approachable after 60 while others become harder isn’t random — it’s that grief either opens people or seals them, and the ones who let loss soften them instead of sharpen them develop a quality that can’t be faked, which is the visible evidence of someone who survived something and chose tenderness over armour

Psychology says the reason some people become warmer and more approachable after 60 while others become harder isn’t random — it’s that grief either opens people or seals them, and the ones who let loss soften them instead of sharpen them develop a quality that can’t be faked, which is the visible evidence of someone who survived something and chose tenderness over armour

Global English Editing

Nobody prepares you for the loneliness of being the last person alive who remembers your mother’s voice, your childhood kitchen, or the sound your father made when he laughed. You become the sole archive of a world that ended, and there’s no one left to verify that any of it happened.

Nobody prepares you for the loneliness of being the last person alive who remembers your mother’s voice, your childhood kitchen, or the sound your father made when he laughed. You become the sole archive of a world that ended, and there’s no one left to verify that any of it happened.

Global English Editing

I’m 73 and I recently realized that almost everything I’ve called “my personality” for the last 40 years was actually a collection of survival responses that hardened into habits — the agreeableness, the efficiency, the emotional steadiness — and the question I’m sitting with now is whether there’s someone underneath all that architecture or whether the architecture is all there ever was

I’m 73 and I recently realized that almost everything I’ve called “my personality” for the last 40 years was actually a collection of survival responses that hardened into habits — the agreeableness, the efficiency, the emotional steadiness — and the question I’m sitting with now is whether there’s someone underneath all that architecture or whether the architecture is all there ever was

Global English Editing

Children who were raised by emotionally distant but materially generous parents often grow into adults with these 10 traits — including the quiet inability to form close friendships even when they desperately want them

Children who were raised by emotionally distant but materially generous parents often grow into adults with these 10 traits — including the quiet inability to form close friendships even when they desperately want them

Global English Editing

I stopped offering to help before anyone asked and within three months my calendar was completely empty – here’s what six months of silence taught me about the difference between relationships and transactions

I stopped offering to help before anyone asked and within three months my calendar was completely empty – here’s what six months of silence taught me about the difference between relationships and transactions

Global English Editing

I’m 65 and I recently realized I can tell you everything about a person’s character within fifteen minutes of meeting them — not from what they say, but from these 9 micro-behaviors that happen before they’ve constructed their social presentation

I’m 65 and I recently realized I can tell you everything about a person’s character within fifteen minutes of meeting them — not from what they say, but from these 9 micro-behaviors that happen before they’ve constructed their social presentation

Global English Editing