Comments

While I agree smoking is a rather disgusting habit, and if it were to go away all together I would not shed a tear, this a great idea.

As a marketer I find this a rather brilliant move. They are creating a haven for smokers while teasing us non-smokers with a hip environment. They've personalized the experience for only those who seek it out.

The lounge living or dying will have more to do with the Bucktown hippsters than the success of this marketing idea...which I feel is rather good one.

This is rather ill-timed considering the smoking ban just passed here in Chicago!

The only thing these ads will do is encourage the already desperately reluctant, ultra-addicted death stickers to gather in one place to enjoy second hand smoke in a dimly lit, oxygen deprived, clothes stinking, red-eyed orgy of cancer.

It would seem logical to me that the manufacturers of cigarettes and those who sell them to consumers be seen as participating in a slow form of assisted suicide. Therefore the only state that should permit the sale of tobacco should be Oregon. The rest of the country should be making room in the cell next to Dr. Kovorkian.

I know I just posted a comment about this, but I have to throw another WTF on the fire.

What good is progress and knowledge if we do nothing with it? Collectively, we know more today about the health damages and WASTED TIME that result from smoking (not to mention dry cleaning bills from the clubbing aftermath) and yet... - are we really that vapid and weak a society that we will continue to allow a couple of morally impotent business men to tell us what is cool? (real cool, emptying your healthy lungs into their bank accounts) Go jog or something!

Yeah ... what happens now that Chicago has a new smoking ban?

Besides ... every person I know who smokes *HATES* smoking lounges. They smoke, yeah, but don't want to stand it a room with a gaggle of other smokers, hacking away, reeking of it.

Stupid, stupid, stupid.

Florida's clean air act prohibits smoking in any public place indoors and restricts it to designated areas outdoors. Only the most severely addicted smoke here any longer - it is now something that is relegated to the lower socio-economic classes - only people who show up in an episode of COPS in their boxers with torn tee shirts and no teeth smoke.

Isn't this just doing for the rich what the company's advertising already does for the poor?

At least the McGearty smokers are more likely to have health insurance that covers smoking cessation than the target market of all the RJR billboards in low-income areas.

Not all of us who smoke will die or get ill from it. Just a relatively small few.

like 400,000 a year ?

Not the most original idea.

Recently saw the Marlborough Lounge at the Lima, Peru airport. A swanky place where you can drink expensive mineral water and martinis as well as smoke before boarding.

Fascinating article. Just one question: Why did you choose to illustrate it with a picture of Mickey Rourke?

1 - As to the timing of this opening, because they're selling cigarrettes, this lounge (an exception as a tobacco store/cigar bar) will allow smokers a place to smoke indoors while the new smoking ban kicks them out of every other venue in town.

2 - True, tobacco smoking is a bad idea. Its day is past. The companies are forced to finance ads to prevent people from starting to use their products, and to help people stop using their products. Right or wrong, the companies are still in business. And there are still some idiots out here smoking. And although I wouldn't be bothered to spend a whole lot of time looking at the grotesque image posted with this post, the artwork for this smoking lounge is admittedly beautiful. Credit where it's due.

Now I'm going out for a smoke. That's right, out, in flippin 40 degree weather. I could use a smoking lounge, dammit. :P

the idea is smart. there is a customer who needs a place to enjoy a legal activity. let the bums who wish to smoke do their thing. it is a free country. bums are allowed to shoot semi-autommatic rifles for target practice throughout rural america. bums are allowed to film and enjoy porno. bums can lure kids with "hip fashion" and "cool cellphones" that are made in overseas sweatshops for pennies a day. let the bums have their smokeshop.

There are times when I am embarrased to be in the marketing profession. The fact that we can do does not translate to we should do it. Great blog photo, did you get it from RJR?

I remember an editorial cartoon in AdAge years back. Three cerial execs standing around a boardroom with a box of Frazzel Flakes in hand. "Well it tastes pretty good and the package is stand-out. Now if we can just find a way to make it addictive".

I guess they gave up and went to work for RJR. Hey isn't Nabisco one of their brands?

Guess that should have been cereal

I think it's a marketing idea with great potential -- I had the idea myself a few years ago, as I'm sure many others did, but it takes capital to create and sustain an operation such as this, so I suppose it had to wait until an RJR would open its deep pockets.

I'm amused by all the hand wringing going on about "Ooooh, smoking is soooo bad, how dare they!.." I thought this site was about whether an idea is good advertising or marketing, not whether you approve of the product or service. Ah well, Americans have always been so parochial and puritanical, it's not surprising, I suppose (read Spanish author Javier Marias' article in the Sunday NY Times, Jan 22nd, by way of comparing national perspectives). Being in Chicago, I'm going to pay a professional-curiosity visit. BTW, the over-the-counter price of a pack of premium cigarettes like Dunhill here in Chicago is around $7.50+, so Marshall McGearty's price of $8 a pack for hand-rolled and custom-selected leaf is actually very reasonable in the local marketplace.

(Oh, and to the smugly self-righteous Florida resident who proclaims that the only smokers in his state are toothless lower-class igs: I'm sure all those real estate developers and their corrupt political partners down there busy raping the wetlands are nice, healthy, upper-class non-smokers, aren't they? Seeing as my father was an Hungarian Count and I'm a moderately well-educated Amherst College alumnus, I guess I can't be allowed to visit Florida and upset the statistics....

I actually live in the neighborhood where the "hipster lounge" is located and have paid it a visit several times. I'd say that calling it a "hipster lounge" is totally off, as the place is actually very nice, has a very friendly staff, is as comfortable as can be, and actually has food better than most of the swanky restaurants in the Wicker Park neighborhood. I am a smoker, so perhaps I appreciate a place where I can sit down, fire up my laptop, have a cup of coffee and a smoke. If you aren't a smoker, don't go... but if you are looking for a place to light up that is outside the restrictions of the newly imposed Chicago smoking ban, then check it out. Aside from the marketing tactics employed here, I am all for it. I don't smoke thier brand, nor will I. I do, however, appreciate a comfortable, friendly place to have lunch though.

Yes, Paul, I will admit we Americans are way too up tight and politically correct about stuff like this. Thought I did write, "everyone should be free to choose their own manner of death," I agree that was harsh. In terms of a marketing idea, it is a very good one. I think all the "don't smoke, don't drink. don't do anything that could possibly add a little fun to your life" American undercurrent got the best of me on this one:-)

And Dave, I guess as "is" was with Clinton, the definition of "hipster" has more than one meaning.

I live next to a student housing high-rise in Brooklyn, and am absolutely astonished at the number of young people who stand shivering outside the entrance (in below-freezing weather, yet) just to get their nicotine fixes. I guess they were surprised to learn about New York's smoking ban.

They have surely heard that smoking is a killer many times, so why do these temporary transplants from Idaho and Mississippi still think that smoking is hip and cool? We might consider smoking to be passe, dangerous or stupid, but the affluent, educated students next door are still buying the message - the smokes.

I live next to a student housing high-rise in Brooklyn, and am absolutely astonished at the number of young people who stand shivering outside the entrance (in below-freezing weather, yet) just to get their nicotine fixes. I guess they were surprised to learn about New York's smoking ban.

They have surely heard that smoking is a killer many times, so why do these temporary transplants from Idaho and Mississippi still think that smoking is hip and cool? We might consider smoking to be passe, dangerous or stupid, but the affluent, educated students next door are still buying the message - the smokes.

Yes, this is an ad marketing blog, but it is impossible to discuss professional merits without including a look at the moral implications that go along with them. As a designer I can appreciate the ads themselves. They do transport and entice, and so I suppose they've done their job.

At least now the smokers have a "ridiculously plush" place where they are free to puff away without offending those of us that don't want to be around it.

oh would you anti-smoking nazis just relax. it's a damn ad. so what? dod you need to control free speech too?

This is a great idea. Plain and simple if you want to smoke...smoke. If you don't...don't. Yes, a clear line, needed to be drawn from those places that allow smoking and those that do not. However, this ban has taken it over the line. The only good think is to see that some wise capitalist found a way around the Daley administration to find a new profitable market. I would love to operate a few of these shops in the cities. The revenue would be off the wall. I don't smoke cigarettes, but love the ocassional cigar. If only the tree huggers could go after McDonalds and Coke. They kill more people in a year than any cigarette company ever did.

OK enough already. Smoking exists. People smoke and drink and eat red meat and screw and do all kinds risky shit. So what? I'm tired of everyone making everyone elses habits their own biz. We are enlightened enough to make our own choices. Please stop meddling in my life.
Also the demonization of smokes is pretty silly on a lot of levels
When, for example did you ever hear of someone kicking the crap out of their wife or kids because they had to much nicotine that day.
Do you know anyone who lost their job because of cig usage?
Has anyone ever been accused of driving under the influence of Marlboro?
2nd Hand smoke kills they say -
You know what - so does 2nd hand alcoholism - where are the thought police marching out against Coors?

OK enough already. Smoking exists. People smoke and drink and eat red meat and screw and do all kinds risky shit. So what? I'm tired of everyone making everyone elses habits their own biz. We are enlightened enough to make our own choices. Please stop meddling in my life.
Also the demonization of smokes is pretty silly on a lot of levels
When, for example did you ever hear of someone kicking the crap out of their wife or kids because they had to much nicotine that day.
Do you know anyone who lost their job because of cig usage?
Has anyone ever been accused of driving under the influence of Marlboro?
2nd Hand smoke kills they say -
You know what - so does 2nd hand alcoholism - where are the thought police marching out against Coors?

Spyro makes good points. I guess smokers need aon organization like the NRA and a similarly snappy slogan -- "Cigarettes don't kill people, people kill people?"

And here's a tactic for the anti-smoking activists: since a lot of Middle Eastern people smoke cigarettes, and a lot of terrorists are from the Middle East, maybe there's a correlation, and smoking cigarettes is a quasi-terrorist activity. Better alert the TSA and the FBI. Look out, Marshall McGearty, soon there might be hidden microphones under your Art
Deco ashtrays!

Spyro makes good points. I guess smokers need aon organization like the NRA and a similarly snappy slogan -- "Cigarettes don't kill people, people kill people?"

And here's a tactic for the anti-smoking activists: since a lot of Middle Eastern people smoke cigarettes, and a lot of terrorists are from the Middle East, maybe there's a correlation, and smoking cigarettes is a quasi-terrorist activity. Better alert the TSA and the FBI. Look out, Marshall McGearty, soon there might be hidden microphones under your Art
Deco ashtrays!

Spyro makes good points. I guess smokers need aon organization like the NRA and a similarly snappy slogan -- "Cigarettes don't kill people, people kill people?"

And here's a tactic for the anti-smoking activists: since a lot of Middle Eastern people smoke cigarettes, and a lot of terrorists are from the Middle East, maybe there's a correlation, and smoking cigarettes is a quasi-terrorist activity. Better alert the TSA and the FBI. Look out, Marshall McGearty, soon there might be hidden microphones under your Art
Deco ashtrays!

Spyro makes good points. I guess smokers need aon organization like the NRA and a similarly snappy slogan -- "Cigarettes don't kill people, people kill people?"

And here's a tactic for the anti-smoking activists: since a lot of Middle Eastern people smoke cigarettes, and a lot of terrorists are from the Middle East, maybe there's a correlation, and smoking cigarettes is a quasi-terrorist activity. Better alert the TSA and the FBI. Look out, Marshall McGearty, soon there might be hidden microphones under your Art
Deco ashtrays!

smoking is bad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

smoking is bad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I smoke. So what. I am only 14!

smokers think the world is their ashtray, just look around. smokers get away with polluting every day, while the rest of us are punished harshly and even prosecuted and thrown into jail. smokers are just some nasty people.

Post a comment

Name:

Email Address:
(Will not display on site. Used for "Send me an email" option below)

URL:
Remember Me? Yes No
Comments: (HTML tags OK for style. URLs will auto-convert to links)

Send me an e-mail if anyone adds comments to this story

If even after clicking Post it seems to take forever for your comment to post, there's no need to click Post again. We're just blaming the problem on a mysterious, impossible-to-find bug we've stopped bothering to attempt to fix.